CyberDrill by HANDVANTAGE

Ten things good facilitators do

One page, taken from the seven Academy lessons. Each point names the lesson it comes from. Watch that lesson for the full method. Each lesson runs about four minutes.

Before the day

1. Agree four things with the client before you choose a scenario. They are the concern, the plan under test, the rules that ask for an exercise, and who signs the report. Write each one down while you are still talking. (Lesson 2)

2. Name the one written plan the exercise tests. Ask for the document itself, its version and its date. If the client has no written plan, say so, because the first piece of work is then the plan. (Lesson 2)

3. Read the whole scenario, then practise it. Check the job titles, the payment days and the approval limits against the client's own. Walk every path the decisions can take. Then do a practice run, which is where you find an update that reads wrong. (Lesson 3)

4. Invite by responsibility. Seat the people who spot, escalate, decide, authorise spend, speak outside the firm and look after staff. If a key person cannot come, invite whoever covers for them. Plan five to eight seats for a first exercise. (Lesson 4)

5. Bring a note taker and a signer. You cannot run the room and take notes at once. Invite the note taker as an observer, and keep them out of the decisions. Plan for an owner or admin who did not run the room to sign the report. (Lessons 2, 4 and 5)

In the room

6. Say how it works before the first update. Name the plan under test. Say the incident is invented and no real system is touched. Say that nobody is being graded, so people can speak freely. Leave the updates and the decisions out of the briefing. (Lessons 1 and 4)

7. Keep the pace. Hold an update when the talk is useful and the next one would cut across it. Send one early when the room has finished and is waiting. Keep your desk open for the whole hour. (Lesson 5)

8. Ask, and let the right person decide. Between updates, your job is to ask. The room discusses and votes. The decision belongs to the person who holds that authority at the client, and you record it. (Lesson 5)

9. Treat what the room says as a claim. A statement in the room is a claim until someone checks it. An exercise touches no real system, so it cannot show that a control works. You and your auditor decide whether a rule is met. (Lessons 1 and 6)

After the hour

10. Run the hot wash in two parts, then give every follow-up an owner and a date. Hold it in the same sitting, with the same people. Part one covers the response against the plan, for about twenty minutes. Part two covers how you ran the exercise, for about ten, and you listen more than you answer. Type one person's name on each follow-up, with a date that person can keep. Hold the after-action meeting within a week, then check at 30 and 60 days and ask to see what changed. (Lessons 6 and 7)

When the room goes wrong

These four are not in the lessons yet. They are the moments a new facilitator finds hardest.

The room goes silent. Wait ten seconds before you speak. It feels long, and it is not. Then ask one role a narrow question, by name: "What would you do in the next five minutes?" Each update lists "Questions you can ask the room". Do not answer for them.

One person answers everything. Thank them, then ask another role by name: "Before we go on, what does finance need here?" If it is the most senior person, ask them to speak last on the next decision. A tile that reads "No entry" shows you who has gone quiet.

Someone argues with the scenario. Agree that it is invented, and write the point under "Notes and parked". Then bring them back: "Suppose it did happen that way. What would you do?" Raise the point in part two of the hot wash.

When to press "Pause". Use "Hold" when the talk is useful and the next update would cut across it. Use "Pause" when the room must stop: a break, a real interruption, or a talk that has left the exercise. Say aloud that the clock has stopped, and say when it starts again.

Which lesson to watch

PointLesson
1, 2Lesson 2: Scoping, and the plan under test
3Lesson 3: Tailoring a scenario
4, 5Lesson 4: Inviting and briefing
6Lesson 1: What a tabletop exercise tests, and what it does not. Lesson 4 covers the briefing
7, 8Lesson 5: Running the hour
9Lesson 1: What a tabletop exercise tests, and what it does not
10Lesson 6: The two-part hot wash. Lesson 7: The after-action meeting

The lessons are at /Academy in CyberDrill.

Running one this week? The run sheet has every step and every button.